Opineko for Insurance Agencies
Help your insurance agency collect more Google reviews with QR codes at policy signings and renewals. Gate negative feedback privately and build client trust.
88% of insurance shoppers read online reviews before choosing an agent or agency
— J.D. Power Insurance Shopping Study, 2024
Challenges Insurance Agencies Face with Reviews
Insurance is a grudge purchase — clients rarely feel motivated to review
Nobody is excited about buying insurance. Clients pay premiums hoping they never need to file a claim. This lack of emotional engagement means insurance agencies receive very few organic reviews compared to businesses that provide experiences customers actively enjoy.
Claims denials generate the most vocal negative reviews
When a claim is denied or a payout is lower than expected, the policyholder feels betrayed — even when the denial is contractually justified. These emotionally charged negative reviews are detailed, passionate, and highly visible to prospective clients researching your agency.
Competing agencies have the same carriers, so reputation is the differentiator
Independent insurance agencies often represent the same carriers and offer similar coverage at similar prices. When products are identical, the agency's online reputation becomes the deciding factor. An agency with 15 reviews loses to a competitor with 100 reviews even if their service is identical.
How Opineko Solves Each Problem
Policy signing and renewal are natural review moments
After a client signs a new policy or completes a renewal, hand them a review card with a QR code. The client just received personalized guidance, found coverage that fits their budget, and feels protected. That sense of security and relief is the ideal emotional state for review collection.
Private feedback captures claims frustration before it goes public
Clients unhappy with claims outcomes are routed to a private feedback form where you can explain the decision, escalate the issue, or find alternative solutions. Claims-related complaints — which are the most damaging type of insurance review — are addressed privately rather than publicly.
Consistent reviews differentiate you from agencies with identical products
When every agency in your market offers the same carriers and similar pricing, a strong review profile becomes your competitive moat. Opineko helps you build that advantage systematically by collecting reviews from every positive client interaction, not just the rare client who reviews on their own.
Best Review Platforms for Insurance Agencies
Review Strategy for Insurance Agencies
Insurance agencies operate in a market where product differentiation is nearly impossible — independent agencies represent the same carriers, offer the same coverage, and often quote similar premiums. When the product is identical, the buying decision comes down to trust, and online reviews are the primary trust signal for consumers researching insurance options. An agency with a strong review profile communicating knowledgeable agents, responsive service, and fair claims handling wins business that would otherwise go to a competitor offering the exact same policies.
The fundamental challenge for insurance review collection is that insurance is what economists call a 'grudge purchase.' Customers buy it because they have to, not because they want to. Nobody celebrates getting a great deal on auto insurance the way they celebrate a great restaurant meal. This low emotional engagement means insurance agencies must be more intentional about creating review collection moments. The two highest-converting opportunities are new policy signings — when the client feels relieved to have found good coverage at a fair price — and successful claims resolutions — when the client has experienced the tangible value of their policy.
Insurance agencies should also recognize that their review strategy serves a dual purpose: attracting new clients and retaining existing ones. When a current policyholder sees their agency actively collecting and responding to reviews, it reinforces their decision to stay. When a prospective client compares two agencies offering identical coverage from the same carrier, the agency with 80 genuine reviews describing responsive, knowledgeable agents wins the business over the agency with 12 reviews every time. In insurance, reviews are not just marketing — they are the primary competitive differentiator in a commoditized market.
Where to Place QR Codes
Frequently Asked Questions
The two best moments are after a new policy signing and after a successful claims resolution. At policy signing, the client feels protected and appreciates your guidance. After a successful claim, the client has experienced the value of their coverage firsthand. Both moments produce genuine, positive reviews.
Opineko routes clients who rate below your threshold to a private feedback form. Claims-related frustration is captured privately so you can explain the decision, escalate if appropriate, or find alternative solutions. For public negative reviews about claims, respond professionally without discussing policy details due to privacy regulations.
Yes. Create separate QR codes for personal lines and commercial lines in Opineko. Commercial clients often provide more detailed, professional reviews that carry significant weight with prospective business clients. Personal lines clients provide volume that boosts your overall rating and local search visibility.
Insurance shoppers increasingly start their search on Google rather than through referrals. Agencies with 50-plus Google reviews and a 4.5-plus star rating appear in the local pack and attract significantly more inbound leads. Reviews are especially important for independent agencies competing against name-brand carriers with large marketing budgets.
Most independent insurance agencies have fewer than 20 Google reviews. Reaching 50 reviews with a 4.6-plus star rating will position you as one of the best-reviewed agencies in most local markets. Because review volume is generally low in insurance, the barrier to standing out is lower than in other industries.
Related Resources
From the Blog
Industries We Serve
Glossary
Sentiment Analysis
The use of natural language processing and text analysis to determine the emotio...
First-Party Reviews
Reviews collected and displayed directly on a business's own website, rather tha...
NAP Consistency
The practice of ensuring that a business's Name, Address, and Phone number are i...
Platform Guides
Ready to Grow Your Insurance Agencies Reviews?
Join hundreds of insurance agencies using Opineko to build their online reputation.
View Pricing